Q&A: Tariffs Matters

18 Nov, 2026
Niven talks about tariffs in the latest Q&A episode

AUT Business School adjunct professor Niven Winchester addresses questions on tariffs, trade wars and their impact on New Zealand's economy and consumers.

Q: What are tariffs and why do they matter?

A tariff is a tax on a good that is imported into a country. Tariffs matter because they influence what consumers purchase and how much they pay for those goods. They also influence producer decisions, encouraging firms to produce different types of goods than they would in the absence of tariffs. This in turn draws resources away from producing other goods, as resources are moved around the economy.

Q: Why is there so much attention on the United States' decision to place tariffs on different countries?

The current situation has been described as a trade shock that occurs roughly once in 100 years. Tariffs at this scale have not been seen for a long time, and they have arrived unexpectedly and at a very high level. Before Trump's second term as president, average US tariffs were below 2%. They now sit at around 20%, with more expected as further tariffs are announced.

Q: New Zealand is a long way from the rest of the world. Are we protected from the potential impact of tariffs?

No, New Zealand is not protected. It is a small open economy without the population base needed to benefit from economies of scale across many goods. New Zealand produces a small number of goods it is well suited to making, such as dairy products, and imports others, such as cars and electronics, from countries including Japan and China. Any disruption to the global trading system ultimately harms New Zealand, even when tariffs are not aimed at it. For example, if tariffs from the United States reduce China's gross domestic product (GDP), New Zealand will experience a flow-on effect, because China will purchase fewer of the goods New Zealand produces.

Q: Can you give an example of what might change for consumers when a country has tariffs placed on its goods?

Consumers are likely to pay higher prices, because a substantial portion of the tariff cost is passed through to consumer prices. This means people pay more for everyday items. New Zealand offers a clear historical example. In the late 1990s, New Zealand had a tariff of 22.5% on motor vehicles, which resulted in an ageing vehicle fleet. Cars cost more than they needed to. People held on to old vehicles for longer, driving vehicles that were less fuel efficient and less safe than the newer models entering the market.

In the United States, the full impact of the current tariffs has not yet been seen. Tariffs have been applied on and off, and firms have been able to stock up on inventory before tariffs take effect. Once those inventories are depleted, larger effects on US consumer prices are expected.

Q: Have tariffs been used historically and, if so, to what effect?

The most well-known historical case is the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act of 1930 in the United States. It involved substantial increases in US tariffs to protect local industry. It is widely believed to have made the Great Depression considerably worse than it would have been without those tariffs. The tariffs prompted retaliation from other countries, and the world was a much worse place as a result.

Q: How do you predict how the new US tariffs will affect different countries?

The analysis uses a global model of production, consumption and trade. This model is built on economic theory and on estimates of how firms and consumers respond to prices. It is calibrated to real-world data.

Q: What is a trade war, and is one happening?

A trade war occurs when two large countries impose tariffs on each other's exports with the goal of harming the other's economy. Whether a trade war is currently under way is difficult to determine. Tariffs in the current global environment have been applied intermittently, with different pauses, different tariff levels and frequent changes. Although it is difficult to say whether a trade war is taking place now, the conditions for one exist in the current global environment and could certainly develop in the future.

Q: Are tariffs punishing consumers rather than countries?

This question prompts consideration of the effects of tariffs on both foreign producers and consumers in the importing country. Consumers clearly pay higher prices when tariffs are imposed. Tariffs can also force foreign firms that want to sell into the US market to accept lower prices for their products, so foreign countries are also harmed. Although the prices foreign firms are willing to accept may fall, that effect is usually small. The larger impact is that consumers pay higher prices.

Q: Should New Zealand introduce tariffs to protect its economy?

No. New Zealand is a small open economy that relies on international trade to obtain the goods it does not produce domestically. Even when other countries place tariffs on New Zealand's exports, the best response is to maintain no tariffs on imports.

Q: Does New Zealand have its own tariffs?

New Zealand does apply tariffs to some isolated products, such as textiles, clothing and footwear. However, the average tariff on New Zealand imports is below 1%, which means the economy is essentially tariff free.

Q: How will the recent US tariff of 15% on New Zealand exporters affect the New Zealand economy?

The effect is mixed. The 15% tariff on New Zealand is lower than the tariff imposed on some other countries. For example, Brazil faces a 50% tariff, which gives New Zealand goods a cost advantage over Brazilian goods in the US market. However, some competitors face lower tariffs. Australia, in particular, faces a 10% tariff, which means New Zealand experiences a small loss when competing against Australian goods in the US market. Modelling by the speaker shows that when these gains and losses are combined, the overall impact on New Zealand is not large, but it is a small negative.

Q: Can New Zealand not simply look to other markets to sell its products?

New Zealand can redirect its exports to other markets, but many other nations are pursuing the same strategy. New Zealand must therefore compete with goods flowing in from other countries, which limits the scope for doing so. Nevertheless, New Zealand can reorganise where it sells its products and, looking ahead, should pursue markets outside the United States.

Q: Do you think the tariffs are here to stay?

It is a well-established result in economics that tariffs harm economies, so the speaker's economic view is that the current tariffs should not persist. However, there is considerable uncertainty about what to expect under the current US administration. The tariffs are likely to remain at least until the end of the current Trump administration. Some tariffs introduced during the first Trump administration were maintained during the Biden administration, so a future with higher tariffs is possible. The speaker hopes that the volatility and higher tariff levels seen in recent months will not continue.

AUT supports the role our academics play as critic and conscience of society, as set out by the Education and Training Act 2020.

Our approach to academic freedom and freedom of expression is set out in our Charter of Academic Freedom which was developed and endorsed by the AUT academic community.